Compromise Of 1850 DBQ
By the 1850’s the Constitution, originally viewed as a document for national unity, had become a source of regional disagreements and tension that eventually resulted in the failure of the Union. The Constitution never outright mentions slavery, and created an unsolved problem that later resulted in compromises and the failure of the Union it formed. The Constitution contributed to the failure of the union because it did not acknowledge slavery which lead to tensions between the Northerners who wanted to abolish it, and the Southerners who considered it an economic necessity. In Document B, a Georgian says that “the constitution does not recognize slavery where it exists”, which proves that the Constitution did not mention slavery or formally
…show more content…
There were many issues with the Compromise of 1850, which was an attempt to create balance, as seen in Document A, between the territories of the North who did not like slavery and the south who wanted slavery. This was an issue because the Fugitive Slave Act required Northerners to help catch slaves who had run away from Southern territory, which was problematic because it interfered with the balance created by the compromise of 1850. Document C shows how kidnappers were sent to catch slaves, and how Northern abolitionists met the South’s rules and regulations with hostility. This shows how the language of the Constitution resulted in regional disagreement and tension and prevented the unity that the document was intended …show more content…
Document G shows President Buchanan’s message to congress which proves the Constitution is not working and needs an amendment. “In any event...themselves from the Union” shows how there is effort made to keep the union together and that amending the Constitution is necessary in doing so. In Jefferson Davis’ message to the Confederate Congress, Document H, he claims that it is “Strange, indeed...and over the States”. As a southerner he is speaking out against the growth of the Northern States and declaring that the Constitution was not a bond between the states, but a national government that was above the States. Additionally, President Lincoln’s message to congress in Document I, which says, “any state of...any other state”, proves that the constitution created a issue that continually grew until it eventually resulted in the failure of the Union it
There were many issues with the Compromise of 1850, which was an attempt to create balance, as seen in Document A, between the territories of the North who did not like slavery and the south who wanted slavery. This was an issue because the Fugitive Slave Act required Northerners to help catch slaves who had run away from Southern territory, which was problematic because it interfered with the balance created by the compromise of 1850. Document C shows how kidnappers were sent to catch slaves, and how Northern abolitionists met the South’s rules and regulations with hostility. This shows how the language of the Constitution resulted in regional disagreement and tension and prevented the unity that the document was intended …show more content…
Document G shows President Buchanan’s message to congress which proves the Constitution is not working and needs an amendment. “In any event...themselves from the Union” shows how there is effort made to keep the union together and that amending the Constitution is necessary in doing so. In Jefferson Davis’ message to the Confederate Congress, Document H, he claims that it is “Strange, indeed...and over the States”. As a southerner he is speaking out against the growth of the Northern States and declaring that the Constitution was not a bond between the states, but a national government that was above the States. Additionally, President Lincoln’s message to congress in Document I, which says, “any state of...any other state”, proves that the constitution created a issue that continually grew until it eventually resulted in the failure of the Union it