Preview

Quebec Should Not Separate from Canada

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1332 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Quebec Should Not Separate from Canada
Quebec should not separate from Canada

Quebec was founded by French settlers during the 16th century. It was then conquered by the British (known as the conquest of New France in 1760). “The Philosophy of the Enlightment” allowed Britain’s victory to treat the French people with dignity as both nations were civilized societies (source?). The British allowed the French occupants to maintain cultural aspects such as language and traditions (source?). In effect, The Quebec Act was published in 1974, in efforts to ensure loyalty from the French as the British government worried that the remaining French people would support the American Independent War (source?). The act was favourable for French people; allowing the continual practice of the French laws in civil cases and redistributing provincial boundaries (source?). After the American War, the 1791 Constitutional Act was introduced; dividing Quebec into two separated provinces: Upper Canada and Lower Canada (source?). This act fulfilled both British and French desires as Upper Canada, which later became Ontario, adopted English as the official language and practiced British Common Law. Lower Canada, where the loyal French resided, chose French as the official language and continued to practice French Civil Laws. One clause of the act that went against French laws was the recognition of the Church of England as the official Church in both Upper and Lower Canada (Couturier and Ouellete Page). This clause soon triggered the conflict between Anglophone and Francophone.
The continuing debate about the sovereignty of Quebec has impacted both the province and Canada. Quebec remained indifferent with the rest of Canada. Their sovereign movements have raised many questions from people residing in Quebec and other provinces. People who supported the sovereignty believed that the identity of Quebec’s French culture is being threatened from the dominance of English speaking people and separation from Canada would help

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Meech Lake accord and Charlottetown Accord can be defined as attempts of Canadian government to make Quebec rejoin the Canadian Constitutional family. P.M Brian Mulrooney wanted that Quebec should symbolically rejoin the Canadian Constitutional family. Therefore, the new premier of Quebec, Robert Bourassa, was asked to outline conditions for such reunion. Mulrooney and premiers met at Meech Lake in April 1987 and agreed on a document that addressed Quebec’s demand and was known as Meech Lake Accord. Prior to this accord government of Quebec “opted out” of the new Charter Of Rights to maximum extend possible under sec. 33 by introducing a “notwithstanding clause” into each of its existing statutes and into every newly acted statues. In addition, the government also refused to participate in new constitutional amendments. Quebec’s this behavior was the result of curbing of its powers by Charter of Rights. Quebec government announced five conditions, these were: (i) Constitutional recognition of Quebec as a “distinct society”. (ii) A veto on constitutional amendments. (iii) Increased jurisdiction over immigration. (iv) participation in Supreme Court appointments. (v) Financial compensation when Quebec opted out of national programs set by Ottawa within provincial jurisdiction. In 1991 a new set of ambitious negotiations began and it was believed that these negotiations would cure everybody’s constitutional discontent as well as Quebec’s. In 1992 the eleven first ministers reached an agreement at Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island. The Charlottetown Accord included all the elements of Meech LakeAccord, and much else besides. For example, regarding the division of legislative powers, it provided for exclusive provincial jurisdiction over forestry, mining and some other areas. It had four main parts : Canada Clause, a Triple-E senate, Aboriginal self-government, and changes to division of powers. The "Canada Clause" set out the values that define the…

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Libs 7002

    • 9345 Words
    • 38 Pages

    Figure 5 : Average debt of students in the last year of an undergraduate degree (dollars)…

    • 9345 Words
    • 38 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The era of late 1700’s was a period of great change in North America. After the French and Indian war ended in 1963, Great Britain’s control of North America’s east coast caused more interaction between the American colonies and Canada, which was a French colony prior to the war. In 1774, the Continental Congress wrote to the inhabitants of Quebec in an appeal which was entitled, “Appeal to the Inhabitants of Quebec.” In this appeal, the American colonists expressed their great joy that Quebec was now a part of the English colonies, and the main thesis of this appeal was that the inhabitants of Quebec had earned the right to have the same rights as the colonies under a just form of government, and that the best way for them to achieve that was by joining the American colonies. These ideas that the colonists had were very persuasive, and they provided a…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This resulted in the establishment of a new political and judicial system in New France. Unfortunately, this approach carried imperialistic intentions and many policies incorporated in the Royal Proclamation displayed an attempt to assimilate the French culture. This resulted in discontent among citizens that led to the institution of the Quebec Act. The Quebec act imparted various rights for the conquered French people; it guaranteed the right to free religious practice, sustaining French civil law, and most importantly allowing Roman Catholics who previously ruled New France to participate in political affairs. The Quebec Act was a significant because marked the inception of citizens challenging authority in order to protect their rights through an official document.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Quebec

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 1608, Samuel de Champlain of France led an expedition which resulted in the founding of Quebec. The French had good relationships with Natives and the colony was funded by fur trade with the Indians. In 1663, New France was no longer managed by the Company of New France, and became directly under the rule of King Louis XIV. In order to grow the population, women were sent to the colony and men migrated to the colony as indentured servants. By 1700, New France had about 15,000 settlers.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After learning about the rebellion of 1837 and constantly taking notes, I realized the rebellion was not successful in overturning the government but it did unite both Upper and Lower Canada together. This was able to take away any differences of the two cultures, English and French. The impact did not happen immediately as intended though. In fact it caused the government to get back at the reformers and concentrate more on their punishment such as transportation, hanging, flogging and deaths for the rebels, instead of working on fixing the colony. You can tell that Canada had a serious political problem that was in desperate need to be improved.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Peter Russel’s work he identifies that a majority of First Nations Canadians “identify with Canada and have an allegiance to it, but they also identify with a historic nation (Russell 232)”. Then there are causes being presented that conflict with the loyalty and dedication to their historic nations and culture, should a banner of Canadian nationalism present itself, it is likely the former will prevail (Russell 232). During the conferences and documented by the video “Dancing Around the Table” there were two quotes that spoke true and emphasized the frustrations of the First Nations people, “the exercise now is not about frank and open discussion, or understanding and appreciation of other peoples’ concerns on the basis of respect and dignity, it has become all of a sudden the question of power and who exercises it (Bulbulian “Dancing Around the Table”).” Just a day after Premiere Rene Levesque confirms that this is a problem, however that it needs to be the First Nations people who are responsible in acquiring power to appropriately negotiate as equals, because it is ultimately the political process (Bulbulian “Dancing Around the Table”). Considering these words were said by one of Quebec’s premiers spoke volumes, because the two groups that possess a dual sense of national identity is both the Quebec and First Nations people (Russell 232). The concerns mentioned by the First Nations representative which is only later confirmed by Rene Levesque demonstrates that what was now occurring, was a dance around the table. There was no genuine or real desire to meet the demands and concerns of the First Nations people, rather than an attempt to humouring them and integrating them into Trudeau’s vision for Canada. This feeling is later confirmed a representative stating that,…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historiography of Quebec

    • 4346 Words
    • 18 Pages

    There has been a great deal of contention surrounding the revisionist perception of Quebec’s normalcy and the traditional understanding of Quebec as a distinct entity. The former attempts to substantiate the shift away from traditional…

    • 4346 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Immigration plays a big role in Montreal’s political and urban geography. Montreal is the primate city of Quebec. The Quebecois work extremely hard on language preservation and maintaining their cultural identity. French is the primary language spoken in Quebec. The Quebecois have the lowest birthrate in all of France. Quebec faces a major problem. They need to bring in immigrants to keep their culture alive, but their culture is also changing by letting in all of these immigrants. Quebec is divided into two areas where there are the English on one side and the French on the other side. The English pose a major threat to the Quebecois. The Quebecois realize that guarding their language is the only way to preserve their culture. In attempts…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government from both Canada East and Canada West couldn’t pass any of the laws, because they needed “double majority”. The problem that the French and the English had, were that they were not agreeing on everything. So nothing got achieved. As the Politician of Canada East said: “ We have five colonies and in order to become a great nation they need only to be brought together under one central Government. The matter comes down to this, either we form a British American Confederation or we will be absorbed into the United States of America.” (Doc…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    CH. 12 Political Space

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages

    -Ex: French-speaking Quebec wanted to secede from Canada; in October of 1995 there was a referendum for this that failed only by a slight margin…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sir guy Carleton replaced James Murray and became the governor of Quebec. He decided to appoint some Canadians into government positions to support the French catholic church. He then traveled to England and for years attempted to convince the British government to change the laws to preserve harmony throughout the colony. Carleton’s acts paid off, the British decided to pass on the Quebec act which have back many rights to the French that they had lost during the Royal Proclamation. As one of the laws state, “ allowance for Catholics to hold political positions without giving up their religion.”…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The province was an unstable society “where rapid changes [had] occurred, but which [had] not absorbed [those] transformations at an equal rate.” Opinions formed on both sides of the arguments concerning separatism, maintaining French culture, and social classes within society. People felt lost amidst the rapid and drastic changes; defined, opinionated, and unwavering groups began to emerge. Some of these were terrorist groups who felt very strongly about the path that Quebec should be taking, and were unafraid to impose their convictions on…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1970s, the Federal Government undertook an official policy on multiculturalism that was based on the understanding that, “…there cannot be one cultural policy for Canadians of British and French origin, another for the original peoples and yet a third for all others. For although there are two official languages, there is no official culture, nor does any ethnic group take precedence over any other.” (Trudeau 1971) If Canada were to establish policies on official cultures, cultures that people must integrate into, the effect would be to increase feeling of alienation in minority communities by creating barriers to entrance. By actively promoting these different cultures, so long as there is a collective will for the…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Good afternoon to you all, My name is Father Lucien I am a fifty (50) years old priest. I have one (1) brother and one (1) sister. I was born in London,England and immigrated to Canada East when I was ten (10) Years old. I lived in Montreal with family. My Father fought against the Fenain's Raid to protect the British North America (BNA) from being taken over by the Irish and help the British, but sadly passed away. I was the first member of my family to become a priest. I recently became interested in politics after I heard about Confederation. I now Represent the Conservatives. I am pretty sure you all have thought about Confederation, But I am here to say it is a horrid idea to join together as a nation. If Canada East joins we will lose our way of life ,Taxes will go up and that will make the poverty rate go up, the taxes would not support the farmers, we might have a massive conflict with the Natives or even a war The representation by population would make the English Speaking Canadians have more say in the government and the House of Commons and will dominate us French speaking Canadians. For these vile reasons I think Confederation is a Horrid idea for Canada East(French Speaking Canadians)…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics