Preview

socrates vs sophist

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
704 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
socrates vs sophist
Intro To Philosophy 1030-202

Socrates was not a Sophist; he never took money for his teaching, and rejected sophistical arguments.For one thing, the sophists taught for money. Socrates did not. For another, the sophists used language to win arguments and to sway people's opinion regardless of the truth. Socrates used language to attain the truth. Socrates lived as an independent man. he did not want to go under any category. He was not paid for his "irony" and maieutics. Therefore he was not a sophist, as being a sophist was having a profession. Socrates was genuinely worried about why the young men were so disappointing. Socrates' young students had been a particular disappointment to him. If Socrates could figure out exactly how the fathers had failed to properly educate their sons, he could save the city and restore Athens to its former glory. Socrates’ interesting idea was that human excellence was really a kind of knowledge. Sophists were skilled in elaborate argumentation; were they would try and make the argument they were focusing on the stronger side, even if it was wrong or weaker. This often made them seem devious as they were working only for the benefit of themselves and their students, who were aiming to become high profile speakers or politicians. Socrates was unlike this in that his main focus was not on argumentation or speaking, he rather focused on questioning virtues to understand morals and ethics. He believed that all opinions were valid which also opposed the views of the Sophists who assumed that the wisest of people were genuinely correct and only they had the ability to teach. The main goal of socrates was unlike that of the sophists. The aim of the Sophists was varied around material possession and desire. They believed knowledge is a means to power and is to be used for political or material gain. Socrates believed his questions would encourage personal growth and create a better society as a whole who would understand

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Socrates, on the other hand, did not concern himself with metaphysics and arché; he studied ethics. Instead of studying the physical world, Socrates strived to find life’s deeper meaning. Socrates’ ideology was different than the rest of the Athenian population. Therefore, the state saw him as a threat. The Sophists, who were the first paid teachers, did not like Socrates or his inadvertent teachings; they taught relativism, or how to win an argument. Socrates was a war hero in at least three Athenian wars. Socrates believed in that which is which eternal and unchanging, such as truths, like love, beauty, justice, and virtue, and absolutism. Socrates that there was one hierarchy of values for all human beings, and…

    • 2221 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Through his constant questioning, torpedo fishing, and gadfly-like behavior, his intentions all were pure, and his actions helped the city to be active and to realize what they don’t know and begin to search for it. Socrates was not a bad person, he acted the way he did because he thought that was the way he should act. “For Socrates, the science of good and bad is simply the science of what condition is naturally, objectively, and actually the ideal condition for a human being.” (Ibid, 171). (Graham 40).…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Classical period was a time of intellectual growth and stimulus. The desire to learn brought about the need for a group of teachers to impart worldly wisdom unto their students. This new group of teachers that emerged were known as "Sophists", which means "those who are wise." Socrates, a great philosopher of the Classical period, challenged the assumed truths of his day in order to reconstruct Athenian life. Plato, Socrates' best student, in turn became a great philosopher in his own rite, and Plato's best student, Aristotle, became a great philosopher himself. These are examples of sustained and confident intellectual motivation and advancement that occurred during the Classical period.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates’ attitude about philosophy, was that every person, choses to do good. Even though it may be a bad or evil decision, to them it is a good decision for them. He believed no person had intentions of evil or wrong doing and if they had knowledge of wrong doing, they would choose to do good instead.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sophism: Plato and Pericles

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The meaning of sophism. In Athens all young aristocrats were getting traditional education in gymnasium. They studied music, poetry, mathematics, athletics, etc. But for some wealthy aristocrats it was not the only education they were getting, they had private tutors that taught them sophism. A number of sources proves the fact that many successful and famous leaders in Athens had sophist teachers. Pericles was one of the most popular leaders in ancient Greece. He had three teachers named Damon, Zeno, and Anaxagoras. Damon was a sophist who taught music. He was teaching Pericles how to speak with confidence, how to use words to affect human psychology. He was using music to show him the art of giving a good speech:…

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The key reason that Socrates felt to educate people in higher thinking was because that was the most justice that he could perform for the city of Athens. Socrates was declared the smartest of all men in Athens by the oracle at Delphi. Socrates explains the words of the oracle, “He went to Delphi at one time and ventured to ask the oracle—as I say, gentlemen, do not create a disturbance—he asked if any man was wiser than I, and the Pythian replied no one was wiser” (Line 21a) The oracle of Apollo did not rest so easy on Socrates’s thoughts. Socrates’ justification is in concert with the oracle, not in contradiction with the oracle or…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Socrates Vs Meno

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the process of learning about virtue at both levels, Socrates also teaches about virtue. Although in the Apology, Socrates claims he is not a teacher, “And if you have heard from anyone that I undertake to teach people and charge a fee for it, that is not true either” (Apology, 19d), he is actually teaching people just by his questioning. Socrates is searching for what virtue is on the cognitive level because he has an actual love for wisdom, and believes knowledge and wisdom will better your soul. “For I go around doing nothing but persuading both young and old among you not to care for your body or your wealth in preference to or as strongly as for the best possible state of your soul…(Apology, 30b). This shows us that Socrates in genuine for wanting to know what virtue is on a cognitive level because knowing what virtue is will better his soul. In the Meno, Socrates questions almost everything Meno says about virtue, and demands a proper definition of it. He even gets frustrated at Meno over it, “Because I begged you just now not to break up or fragment virtue, and I gave examples of how you should answer. You paid no attention…” (Meno, 79b). Socrates is getting frustrating at this point in the dialogue because Meno will not tell him what virtue actually means, or if he truly does not know what it means. During the back and forth arguments between Meno and Socrates while trying to determine the meaning of virtue, Socrates is unintentionally teaching Meno. Every time Socrates questioned Meno or his definitions, it made Meno take a step back and have to think about what he was saying. This lead Meno to have to further explain himself, or completely change his train of thought. This type of teaching that Socrates is demonstrating focuses more on questioning then giving answers. It makes the student do some of their own critical thinking and…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates was trying to figure out what virtue is and instill it in the youth. Meno informed us of that. Meno had a conversation with Socrates about the definition of virtue. Socrates said that he never met anyone who could define virtue, but was challenging Meno to come up with the definition. He also challenged Meno to leave his Sophist’s teacher’s views out of it. He wanted to hear Meno’s own words. Socrates wasn’t going to give up, in the pursuit of, the true explanation of virtue. Meno had several definitions of virtue that were close to being right but were a little bit off. These answers didn’t cut it for Socrates, and nothing but the truth would satisfy him.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates Protagoras

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Socrates asks Protagoras "in respect to what" will Hippocrates improve by associating with him, in the manner that by associating himself to a doctor he would improve in medicine (318d). Protagoras begins his discourse with the statement that a good sophist can make his students into good citizens. Socrates says that this is fine and good, but that he personally believes that this is not feasible since virtue cannot be taught (319b). He adds that technical thinking can be imparted to students by teachers, but that wisdom cannot be. By way of example, Socrates points to the fact that while in matters concerning specialised labour one would only take advice from the appropriate specialist, like for example builders (τέκτονες) about construction, in matters of state everyone's opinions is considered, which proves that political virtue is within everyone, or that at least that is what Athenians in their democratic ideals believe. Another example is that Pericles did not manage to impart his wisdom to his sons (319e). Socrates' uses a similar example in the Meno. He then…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates A Tyrant

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although Socrates was considered an intelligent man and a great teacher, perhaps the greatest teacher of his time, Socrates did not consider himself wise in all matters. In fact after questioning a man who had a great reputation for being wise Socrates explained, “The fact is neither of us know anything beautiful and good, but he thinks he does know when he doesn’t, and I don’t know and don’t think I do; so I am wiser than he is by only this trifle, that what I do not know I don’t think I do” (Mitchell 31). By revealing that the prominent citizens of Athens—those in positions of respect and power—were not as wise as they claimed to be, by proving that they thought they knew something that set them apart from the common man, but in actuality they did not, Socrates acquired many enemies. Moreover, since Socrates’ favorite target was the intellectual elite he acquired many enemies with the power and political influence to silence…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates was a Greek philosopher who challenged the thinking of many and taught away the ignorance of others. However, Socrates was too smart for his own good and eventually found himself imprisoned in Athens and on death row due to what he claims were false charges. Prior to his exile, Socrates partook in a particularly interesting situation where he taught an individual, his friend Meno, about the mysteries of life. Together the two talked about many things such as what is virtue, what is just, and how to come to know if something is true. Furthermore, in this conversation Socrates does a very good job in explaining to Meno that knowledge holds more value than true opinion. I agree with and believe that Socrates was correct in his assessment of knowledge vs. true opinion.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Defense of Socrates

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Socrates' argument was unique in that he tried to convince the jury he was just an average man and not to be feared, but in actuality demonstrated how clever and tenacious he was. He begins with an anecdote of his visit to the Oracle of Delphi, which told him that there was no man smarter than he. He, being as humble as he is, could not take the Oracle's answer for granted and went about questioning Athenians he felt surpassed his intelligence. However, in questioning politicians, poets, and artisans, he found that they claimed to know of matters they did not know about. Socrates considered this to be a serious flaw, and, as Bill S. Preston, Esq. put it: that "true wisdom consists in knowing that you know nothing."…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opinions on Socrates

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This is a point of view that I take because it is something I find myself doing. If there is a topic that I am passionate about, it bothers me greatly when someone else acts like they know everything about the topic. This is especially true if I have knowledge that they're wrong in some form. In this situation I find myself doing much like Socrates…I get the other person to talk in circles and make them admit that they're wrong. What bothers me is not that the person is saying something that I know to be wrong, but mostly that they infer that they are knowledgeable about the topic and act like they know everything about it. In the conversations of Socrates that I've read, admittedly not more than a dozen, he tends to do the same thing. Socrates even admits this in the Apology when…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Plato

    • 2312 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In the Apology, Plato provides a narrative of Socrates' defence for using the elenchus, an exhaustive questioning method, to stir the position of Athenian citizens on traditional values (Jowett, 2009). Derived from various arguments in The Apology, Crito, and The Republic, it can be found that Socrates had two motives for his conduct. The first motive stems from his notion of benefit in the spiritual realm, which is derived from his theory of virtue. He held that the best life for humans is a life of virtue, and a life of virtue entailed striving to comprehend the true essence of values (Jowett, 2009). The practice of valuing true knowledge was seen to be…

    • 2312 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early on, Socrates had clearly established to the Athenian 's that he was not a Sophist. He had no intention to teach for money but instead to spread his new ideas through conversation. Socrates empathized morality and the importance of justice leaving the Athenian society completely baffled. No one had ever experienced a philosopher who centralized his ideas on ethical beliefs.Socrates main ideas included finding the true knowledge of justice and choosing good over evil inevitably leading to a happy life. In one instance, Socrates refused to put a group of generals who had lost sailors in a storm to death all at once but rather insisted that they had to be tried individually, as the law stated. A fellow philosopher Xenophon recounts that the assembly and powerful men were angry with him but he would rather be punished then insult justice (8). Clearly, Socrates was completely focused on moral knowledge leading to a good life. Aristotle uses a different way to describe Socrates intentions claiming that Socrates used certain comparisons to strengthen his claim. Aristotle says, "Then they are the sort of comparisons Socrates used. For example, If someone says that people should 't be chosen by lot to hold office, that 's just like someone appointing athletes should ignore those who are the best competitors, and pick at random"(3). Socrate 's fellow citizens however could not disagree more. Their concepts expressed the importance of public success and wealth, intentionally focusing on individual virtue rather than the…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays